Shumsky Idea Box
Competitive Marketing Communications Audit
Introduction
This document will present an overview of your competitors’ marketing communications materials to help you develop and determine how your corporate and business unit-focused design and positioning will best differentiate you in the market place.
Audit details
For each identified competitor, this audit will collect examples of the following aspects of its marketing communications:
- Corporate logo
- Corporate positioning statement
- Corporate tagline
- Product names and logo marks
- Product positioning statements
- Corporate and product brochures
- Selected web pages
- Selected advertising layouts
- Selected direct mail pieces
Additionally, this audit will capture key positioning statements and value proposition language to assess common phrases and ideas, as well as key phrases that may be unique to a given competitor. To do so, this audit will complete a matrix that aggregates competitors’ key language.
The list of competitors can be organized by your business units or brands, by industry served, or other designation. In some cases a competitor will compete in more than one area. If so, the audit will list the competitor only once but will identify all of the areas in which it competes.
Section 1 – Competitor examples
Name:
HQ Address:
Website URL:
Areas in which this company competes: (list all that apply)
Checklist of collected marketing communications materials: (printouts or electronic versions of each item should be pasted into or attached to this section)
Corporate logo |
|
Corporate positioning statement |
|
Corporate tagline |
|
Product names and logo marks |
|
Product positioning statements |
|
Corporate and product brochures |
|
Selected web pages |
|
Selected advertising layouts |
|
Selected direct mail pieces |
|
Name:
HQ Address:
Website URL:
Areas in which this company competes: (list all that apply)
Checklist of collected marketing communications materials: (printouts or electronic versions of each item should be pasted into or attached to this section)
Corporate logo |
|
Corporate positioning statement |
|
Corporate tagline |
|
Product names and logo marks |
|
Product positioning statements |
|
Corporate and product brochures |
|
Selected web pages |
|
Selected advertising layouts |
|
Selected direct mail pieces |
|
Name:
HQ Address:
Website URL:
Areas in which this company competes: (list all that apply)
Checklist of collected marketing communications materials: (printouts or electronic versions of each item should be pasted into or attached to this section)
Corporate logo |
|
Corporate positioning statement |
|
Corporate tagline |
|
Product names and logo marks |
|
Product positioning statements |
|
Corporate and product brochures |
|
Selected web pages |
|
Selected advertising layouts |
|
Selected direct mail pieces |
|
Name:
HQ Address:
Website URL:
Areas in which this company competes: (list all that apply)
Checklist of collected marketing communications materials: (printouts or electronic versions of each item should be pasted into or attached to this section)
Corporate logo |
|
Corporate positioning statement |
|
Corporate tagline |
|
Product names and logo marks |
|
Product positioning statements |
|
Corporate and product brochures |
|
Selected web pages |
|
Selected advertising layouts |
|
Selected direct mail pieces |
|
Section 2 – Positioning matrix
This exercise will help you identify competitive products and services as well as frequently used phrases and ideas in positioning your competitive products and services. Additionally, you will identify unique positioning among competitive products and services.
Competitive products and services matrix
[See business unit for existing matrices]
Key phrases and ideas matrix
|
“Low cost” |
“Full-service” |
Key phrase |
Key phrase |
Key phrase |
Competitor 1 |
|
|
|
|
|
Competitor 2 |
|
|
|
|
|
Competitor 3 |
|
|
|
|
|
Unique competitive positioning
|
Phrase, idea, or product position |
Competitor 1 |
|
Competitor 2 |
|
Competitor 3 |
|









